Those Rock and Roll Hall of Fame shows set for October at Madison Square Garden: they’re already causing controversy.
Missing from the rosters on both nights are just about everyone important: Bob Dylan, Paul McCartney and Ringo Starr, the Rolling Stones, Van Morrison, Elton John, Sting, Bonnie Raitt, Carole King, The Eagles, Billy Joel, Steve Winwood, not to mention the Kinks and the Who, Fleetwood Mac, and so on.
The listings omit both women and blacks with the exception of Stevie Wonder and Aretha Franklin. How sad, and stupid. Smokey Robinson, Diana Ross and the Supremes, Gladys Knight, Lionel Richie–all missing. Al Green, Little Richard, Chuck Berry, Sam Moore, Booker T, Mavis Staples, Gene Chandler, Percy Sledge, all the doo-wop groups, Dion and the Belmonts– missing.
What this is: a Rolling Stone magazine celebration cloaked as the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. Otherwise, Chubby Checker would start the show with “The Twist.” But he’s not even in the Rock Hall. So there!
And where are the chicks, so to speak? Joni Mitchell, Judy Collins, Carly Simon, Linda Ronstadt, who made Rolling Stone so big in the 70s? Or all the punky rock groups from the Phil Spector era, or Darlene Love? Something tells me there are going to be lots of medleys led by the indefatigable Paul Shaffer, in between the big acts already announced. It will be like one of those hideous PBS singalongs from Pittsburgh.
And what of the O’Jays, the Dells, the Chi Lites, the Stylistics and Earth Wind and Fire? Blondie, the Cars, the Ramones, the Pretenders and Talking Heads? Elvis Costello? Patti Smith? George Clinton?
And Joel Peresman gets $376,000 a year. It boggles the mind.


The audience, as you might imagine, was stocked with the top folks in broadcast journalism. From CBS: Don Hewitt, Les Moonves, Harry Smith, Katie Couric, Bob Schieffer, Morley Safer, Russ Mitchell, Bill Plante, and Dan Rather. Connie Chung, John Roberts, ex of CBS, now of CNN, and Jeff Greenfield were there. From NBC: Tom Brokaw (with wife Meredith), Matt Lauer, Meredith Vieira, Lester Holt, Brian Williams. From ABC: Diane Sawyer as well as Charlie Gibson and Barbara Walters (pictured). I think Walter would have been amused to see Jerry Stiller and Ann Meara, and former Mayor David Dinkins.
Alas, there will be no major Diva Face Off at the next Grammy Awards.