Thursday, June 4, 2026

‘American Idol’ Producer: Elton Still Best Simon Replacement

Share

This is a pretty good week for Sir Elton John.

On Monday night, former “American Idol” producer Nigel Lythgoe told me ‘ when I ran into him at the new Beverly Hills Soho House ‘ that he still thinks Sir Elton is the best choice to replace Simon Cowell. “He’s absolutely it,” said Lythgoe, who also said he thinks Ellen DeGeneres is still warming up and has yet to show her full potential. And he misses Paula Abdul. “She was the glue that held it together, wasn’t she?” he said wistfully.

On Sunday night Sir Elton hosted his annual Oscar dinner and party at the Pacific Design Center. Tons of A listers filled up the tents to hear Grace Jones and rub elbows with stars like Betty White, Jamie Foxx, Joaquin Phoenix, Jennifer Hudson, Salma Hayek, Will.i.am, Josh Groban, Malin Akerman, Slash, John Waters, the Osbournes, Hayden Panettiere, Victoria Beckham, Heidi Klum, Alan Cumming, Serena Williams, Nick Jonas, Kara DioGuardi, Simon Cowell ‘‘who was driven around in a $540,000 Rolls Royce Phantom ”Miley Cyrus, and even, as an oddity, Perez Hilton! Grace Jones was wild, outrageous, as good as ever. The party planners created an all red nightclub for her within Elton’s tents. It was quite a treat.

Then, last night: at the Helen Hayes Theater, Elton and David Furnish hosted a pre-opening night on Broadway for a wonderful new play they’ve put their names on as producers, called “Next Fall.” Whoopi Goldberg, Edie Falco, David Schwimmer, Donna Karan and Lorraine Bracco, director Doug Liman, and Oscar winning “Amadeus” director Milos Forman were in the audience to see this very funny and moving dramedy by Geoffrey Nauffts. Patrick Breen and Maddie Corman are standouts in this story of love and loss, but everyone in the cast is spot on ‘ especially Cotter Smith as a redneck dad who might be hipper than we think. Among Nauffts’ many laughs are several thought provoking conversations about religion and sex and death. Bravo to Elton and David for giving this play a leg up!

So that’s Sunday, Monday, and Wednesday. “Next Fall” has its real opening tonight, with more accolades. What will Elton do on Friday? Sleep?

Donate to Showbiz411.com

Showbiz411 is now in its 13th year of providing breaking and exclusive entertainment news. This is an independent site, unlike the many Hollywood trades that are owned by one company. To continue providing news that takes a fresh look at what's going on in movies, music, theater, etc, advertising is our basis. Reader donations would be greatly appreciated, too. They are just another facet of keeping fact based journalism alive.
Thank you


Roger Friedman
Roger Friedmanhttps://www.showbiz411.com
Roger Friedman is the founder and editor-in-chief of Showbiz411. He wrote the FOX411 column on FoxNews.com from 1999 to 2009 and previously edited Fame magazine and wrote the "Intelligencer" column at New York magazine. His bylines have appeared in The New York Times, The Washington Post, the New York Daily News, the New York Post, Vogue, Details, and the Miami Herald. He is a voting member of the Critics Choice Awards (Film and Television branches), and his movie reviews are tracked by Rotten Tomatoes. is articles have appeared in dozens of publications over the years including New York Magazine, where he wrote the Intelligencer column in the mid 90s and covered the OJ Simpson trial, and Fox News (when it wasn't so crazy) where he covered Michael Jackson. With D.A. Pennebaker and Chris Hegedus, he co-produced the 2002 documentary "Only the Strong Survive," which screened at Directors' Fortnight at the Cannes Film Festival.

Read more

In Other News